Jessica earned 15 varsity letters playing volleyball, basketball, and softball. She was selected as a team captain nine times and team MVP seven times. Jessica was named to Section V All-Tournament Teams on eight occasions, and was named an LCAA All-Star 12 times.

During her basketball career, Jessica was selected as an LCAA All-Star three times and named to the Section V All-Tournament team twice. She was also selected to the All-Greater Rochester Honorable Mention team on two occasions. Her 886 career points ranks third on the Warsaw all-time scoring list.

During her five years on the softball team, Jessica amassed 237 strikeouts and a 1.12 ERA while hitting .437. She was a four-time LCAA All-Star and a three-time Section V All-Tournament team player. In her six years on the volleyball team, Jessica was a five-time LCAA All-Star. During this time, Jessica made the Section V All-Tournament team four times, including being selected as the Section V MVP on their runner-up team in 2003. Her career total of 1,702 kills and 1,699 digs are the most in Warsaw history.