Jamie earned 12 varsity letters as a member of the soccer, basketball, track, and baseball teams. He was selected as an LCAA All-Star in his only season playing baseball for the Tigers.

Jamie is considered by many to be the best soccer player in Warsaw history. During his four-year career, he served as captain, and was named an LCAA All-Star three times. He was also selected as team MVP. He holds school records for goals in a career (65), goals in a single season (24), and career points (87). He ranks second in single season points (30) and career assists (22).