-
SIX PROFILES OF GIFTED BEHAVIOR
George Betts & Jolene Kercher
TYPE I: Successful
Teacher pleasers- smart, alert, ready to please
Sacrifice creativity and autonomy for conformity
Score high on ability and achievement
Identified gifted as a reward for the kind of student they are
Need enhancement as learners, not as students
TYPE II: Challenging
Non-conformers, rebels, don’t learn like the rest of their peers
Fight the system; frustrated that teachers don’t meet their diverse needs
Don’t reveal their creativity and autonomy; possibly more boys
Individuality is more important than conformity
Many are not identified as gifted because of behavior and lack of control
Suffer because of lack of success
Need to learn self management and the ability to work within the system
TYPE III: Underground
Possibly more social girls in middle school
Hide their creativity and intelligence because they want to belong.
They don’t want to be gifted especially if their friends aren’t
Boys begin this in elementary school.
Need to understand self
TYPE IV: Dropout
Dislike themselves, their teachers, and many times their parents
Beyond bored and frustrated to resentful and angry
Drop out of school early, drop out of life
Attempt or commit suicide
Can’t cope with pressures
Need early intervention focusing on the whole person, not just intellectual
TYPE V: Twice Exceptional
Learning disabled and gifted
Hearing impaired and gifted
Other disabilities and gifted
Usually identified only for special education and not for gifted
Work on strengthsTYPE VI: Autonomous Learner
Comfortable as a student and a learner
Don’t sacrifice creativity while developing intellectually
Don’t sacrifice individuality for conformity
Often identified