NOTING: Most Handsome and Most Beautiful were chosen from 1959 to 1966. Beauties of Troy was established in 1967 and continued until 1991. In 1992, a Court of Troy was established to include male contestants. The tradition appears to have been discontinued after 1997.
- 1959: Tom Church and Sue Wolf
- 1960: Dennis Breeden and Carol Swanson
- 1961: James Poston and Sheran Bishop
- 1962: Norton White and Reginia Miller
- 1963: Lanny Darby and Pat Beamguard
- 1964: Bill Ahrens and Kay Crumpler
- 1965: Andy Thacker and Darlene Rierson
- 1966: Johnny Blackwell, Donna Allen
- 1967: Kay Amason, Marcia Leigh Dunham, Landa Lee, Ann Rigby
- 1968: Gloria Guynn, Ruth Hale, Mary Johnson, Melody Schwalm, Karen White
- 1969: Pam Baughman, Janet Howard, Loresa Martin, Dawn Zinnecker
- 1970: Cyndy Berger, Johnnie Cucco, Karen Day, Susan Shutt, Rhonda Williams
- 1971: Sandra Bundy, Linda England, Debbie Hamilton, Karen Jones
- 1972: Cindy Sheppard, Carrie Bentley, Shelley Lee, Ami McDonald
- 1973: Lynn Lewis, Beth Speights, Bette Sullivan, Elece Wooler
- 1974: Rosalyn Torres, Pam Hamilton, Sharon Biles, Laura McDonald
- 1975: Carol Janak, Dawn Sanders, Tracy Trahan, Jeffrey Wright
- 1976: Lori Odom, Susan Dinsdale, Debbie Phillippo, Tricia Green, Kathy Fowler
- 1977: Robin Reese, Marcie Vantrease, Vanessa Kirby, Kathy Johnson
- 1978: Teri Daniel, Lynda Kaye Owens, Debbie Oliver, DeeAnn Pederson
- 1979: Dawn Powell, Michelle Owens, Lisa Veale, Kim Maddux, Sherry Cogbill
- 1980: Missy Henson, Heidi Green, Robin Baker, Sarah Chambers, Lisa Gilbreath
- 1981: Cindy Irving, Pam Reese, Jennifer Dunga, Tina Montgomery, Leigh Anne Van Natter
- 1982: Diana Beavers, Danielle Peifer, Karen Flint, Nina Copley, Twila Lanier
- 1983: Luci Marez, Yvette Nutt, Melanie Airington, Karan Duba, Leann Bolton
- 1984: Jessica Williams, Lori Pritchard, Rebecca Reid, Michelle Garcia, Shelly Callon
- 1985: Dana Johnson,Emily Hernandez, Kathy Shapley, Ann Sebesta, Beth Poehl
- 1986: Michelle Camario, Tracie Martin, Jennifer James, LaNeese Lehrmann, Rachelle Solley
- 1987: Trudi Gallardo, Sheri Green, Teri Haley, Debra Logan, Laura Smith
- 1988: Robin Loe, Angie Bourgeois, Christi Fernandez, Julie Lirette, Audrey Peake
- 1989: Jamie Ball, Stephanie Brown, Peggy Gutierrez, Laura Lamont, Tammy Slay
- 1990: Stacey Dement, Rana Fisher, Brandy Harrison, Christi Sharpe, Wendy Struss
- 1991: Josette Fuentez, Julie Hall, Angel Grady, Jennifer Hall, Traci High
- 1992: Myla Cowan, Aynna Neves, Misty Roach, Melissa Aranza, Shelli Cooper, Charles Lamont, Jason Curtis, Tim Lyles, Jesse Blair, Richard Peters
- 1993: Kim Crumpler, Amber Meeker, Lisa Lopez, Michelle Monreal, Teresa Maldonado, Jeremy Soto, Noel Ortiz, Steve Chmaitelli, Jeremy Barber, Jason Johnson
- 1994: Angela Morgan, Alisha Santos, Ellen Williams, Teresa Eckelkamp, Heather Tryon, Eric Dulany, Chris Sully, Pete Rangel, Daniel Petter, Erskine Branch
- 1995: Mandi Trittipo, Dominque Babin, Kelly Roberts, Monica Garcia, Audra Childers, Sean Franklin, Bert Ferris, Cuong Tran, Casey Vanarsdel, Rene Carvajal
- 1996: Jennie Simons, Lorrie Picazo, Nicole Kuykendall, Daney Delao, Marsha Nail, Brent Gutierrez, Nathan Milligan, Joseph Curtis, Danny Newell, Kenneth Shak
- 1997: Joanna Guerra, Michelle Laughlin, Laura Ortiz, Christy Tremont, Elizabeth Turney, Kristopher McGrew, Derek Temple, Michael Stratigakis, Nick Torina, Michael Butera